Chinese Yuan: Reserve data divergence raises FX questions – Commerzbank

Volkmar Baur at Commerzbank highlights a growing discrepancy between China’s official reserve data and SAFE settlement figures, suggesting Chinese banks are accumulating foreign currency that does not appear on PBoC’s balance sheet. He discusses a plausible interpretation that the PBoC may be intervening in the FX market while parking resulting assets within the state banking system to avoid visible reserve increases.

Hidden intervention via state banks

"Data released yesterday provide further evidence that the PBoC may be intervening in the FX market without allowing those interventions to show up in its headline reserves. Official data put the increase in China’s foreign-exchange reserves at just USD 5bn in October. Yet SAFE’s settlement data tell a very different story: Chinese banks purchased a net USD 65.2bn in foreign currency from domestic exporters during the month."

TMGM талдауы: Қаржы нарығы жаңалықтары, экономикалық күнтізбе және нарықтық шолулар

"Historically, these two series have moved broadly in tandem. The data going back to 2006 show that, prior to the pandemic, excess foreign currency accumulated by Chinese banks generally found its way onto the PBoC’s balance sheet. Banks had little incentive to retain FX they did not need and assume the associated currency risk."

"But that relationship has broken down since the pandemic. On a rolling six-month basis, the divergence has become particularly striking since late last year. In other words, Chinese banks are accumulating foreign currency that neither leaves the country nor appears in the PBoC’s official reserves."

"One plausible explanation is that the PBoC is intervening in the FX market but parking the resulting foreign-currency assets elsewhere in the state banking system, thereby avoiding an increase in headline reserves that would make the intervention more visible."

"The rise in foreign-currency assets held by state-owned banks is consistent with this interpretation, although the PBoC disputes that it is intervening in this way. While this does not constitute definitive proof, the widening discrepancy is becoming increasingly difficult to dismiss."

(This article was created with the help of an Artificial Intelligence tool and reviewed by an editor. Know more.)