【TMGM Financial Recap】November 19 Summit in Shenzhen to Bring Leaders of China, Russia and US Face to Face for First Time Since World War II

Fewer than 50 Chinese characters made up the news bulletin issued by Xinhua on the morning of November 16, announcing a meeting of three world leaders. A Foreign Ministry spokesperson said President Xi Jinping would meet Russian President Vladimir Putin and US President Donald Trump in Shenzhen on November 19. Never before have the leaders of China, Russia and the United States met face to face; the gathering will also be the first such trilateral summit since World War II.

TMGM Analysis: Financial Market News, Economic Calendar & Market Insights

Global nuclear arms reductions and the Middle East conflict will feature in the talks, but the Russia–Ukraine war will not, the White House has explicitly stated. That agenda differs from the Kremlin’s: efforts by Putin to secure Ukraine’s inclusion have been rejected by US officials. No particular subjects were named in China’s official statement.

For the US, “nuclear disarmament and Iran.” are the selected priorities. Ahead of the summit, Trump has used several public statements to underline its focus on global nuclear arms control and an end to the US–Iran conflict. He has sought nuclear disarmament repeatedly since his first term, with no progress to show for those efforts. More pressing is his need to find a diplomatic route forward on Iran. The increase in oil prices brought about by the war was one of the main factors behind the Republican Party’s defeat in the midterm elections. There is relatively little political cost to Trump in raising either issue. Another failure to agree on nuclear disarmament would fit the historical pattern; progress of any kind on Iran, by contrast, would offer a political gain.

“Ukraine and the European security architecture.” are Russia’s chosen priorities. It was Putin who first suggested a trilateral summit on the sidelines of APEC in Shenzhen, envisaging Ukraine as the principal subject. Moscow’s underlying aims, however, go beyond Ukraine. Russia may be seeking a restructuring of Europe’s security order on a scale unmatched since the end of the Cold War, according to a report by The Indian Express. A meeting of the three leaders provides a chance to shift that objective from a European matter to one pursued through coordination between major powers. With China and the United States joining discussions on Europe’s security architecture, Putin could present Russia as a major power equal to both, rather than as a state isolated by Europe.

By leaving the agenda undefined, China is retaining room for manoeuvre. In-depth exchanges on maintaining world peace and promoting strategic stability in relations among major powers were envisaged in the Foreign Ministry’s statement. There were no named topics, predetermined outcomes or demands put forward for either side. An analysis published on Sohu read the approach in these terms: “Whoever rushes to set the agenda must take responsibility for its success or failure.” As host, China is providing the setting and access, leaving each participant to propose the matters it wishes to raise. Its reluctance to shape the agenda also conveys a position: at a trilateral meeting unlikely to yield a substantive agreement, China has no intention of endorsing either side’s priorities.

Substantive negotiations may not materialise if the three sides arrive at the summit without even minimal agreement on the subjects to be discussed. Instead, proceedings may consist of setting out their respective positions and exchanging terms. That prospect was described in an analysis published on China.com: “Even if the meeting between the three leaders takes place, it is more likely to provide a platform for expressing positions and exchanging terms than to replace negotiations among the parties concerned.”