Brothers accused of $25M Ethereum MEV exploit acquitted by US judge

  • The Peraire-Bueno brothers secured an acquittal from a US federal judge over allegations of wire fraud.
  • By allegedly exploiting a relay vulnerability in MEV-Boost, the brothers intercepted transaction bundles from automated trading bots and extracted $25 million.
  • Following a mistrial in 2025, the judge acquitted the brothers and also dismissed the related charge of conspiracy to commit money laundering.

Allegations of a $25 million exploit of Ethereum's maximal extractable value (MEV) infrastructure have ended in acquittal for brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno. A US federal judge ruled that prosecutors had not established the material misrepresentations necessary to prove wire fraud.

TMGM Analysis: Financial Market News, Economic Calendar & Market Insights

Why did the multi-year fraud case against the Peraire-Bueno brothers end in acquittal?

Finding that the evidence presented at trial could not lead a reasonable jury to convict, US District Judge Jessica G. L. Clarke approved the brothers' motion for judgment of acquittal on Monday.

At the heart of the case was Omakase, an operation carried out in April 2023. The brothers allegedly induced automated trading bots to submit transactions that appeared profitable, then intercepted the trades to extract $25 million in crypto within 12 seconds.

For the wire fraud charges to stand, prosecutors needed to show that the brothers had made material false representations during the operation. Clarke found that they had not done so. The prosecution's argument was that the brothers intentionally devised bait transactions to convince automated sandwich trading bots that profitable opportunities were available.

Transaction bundles holding millions of dollars in crypto were then submitted by the bots. According to the allegations, the brothers gained access to these private transactions through a vulnerability in MEV-Boost's relay infrastructure and substituted their own transactions for the proposed block contents. The targeted traders were left facing substantial losses.

Clarke nevertheless concluded that the bait transactions offered no promise of inclusion in the bots' bundles, nor any assurance that the brothers would permit their trades to be sandwiched.

Nor did the judge accept that an invalid block header submitted with a digital signature amounted to a material misrepresentation. Prosecutors, she noted, had not shown how the allegedly false information affected a material decision made by the relay.

On the evidence before it, the court also concluded that validator registration, a request for a block and the proposal of a modified block did not amount to material misrepresentations. Clarke drew a distinction between breaching MEV-Boost's intended design and committing wire fraud: the prosecution had not identified a falsehood that was legally actionable.

Following their arrest in May 2024, the Peraire-Bueno brothers faced charges of conspiracy to commit wire fraud, wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering. Prosecutors alleged that the operation involved months of preparation and that the brothers later acted to conceal its proceeds.

Trial proceedings began in October 2025. After nearly four weeks, however, a Manhattan federal jury could not reach a unanimous verdict, prompting Clarke to declare a mistrial on November 7, 2025.

The latest ruling also removed the money laundering conspiracy charge because it relied on the alleged proceeds of wire fraud. The judge found that, in the absence of the underlying wire fraud offence, the necessary predicate criminal activity had not been established.